Vatican legal specialist backs Pope Francis’ current disciplining of dissident bishops

VATICAN CITY (RNS)– As Pope Francis faces bold bishops in Germany and the United States, a high-ranking Vatican authorities who manages church law clarified on Tuesday (Nov. 28) the procedures for disciplining a bishop, stating any failure to act in communion with the church and the pope can be trigger for termination.

“There is no main system for the shooting of bishops, which can be examined by the college of bishops and by the pope,” stated Bishop Juan Ignacio Arrieta, secretary of the Vatican Department for Legislative Texts, at a conference with journalism arranged by the Pontifical University of the Holy Cross.

Arrieta discussed that a church trial is just essential if the bishop is implicated of a criminal activity. “Sometimes it’s a concern of a single act, others it’s a problem of conduct,” he stated, while in other cases the bishop’s habits might need “an assessment of communion” with fellow bishops and the pope.

Popes seldom take the action of shooting dissenting bishops, rather choosing to ask for a letter of resignation that remains in turn accepted by the pontiff. On Nov. 12, Francis dismissed Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, a strong critic of the pope and a prominent voice of the conservative opposition to Francis in the United States. Strickland’s diocese had actually been put under Vatican examination previously this year after he had actually made a routine of passing along criticism of the pope on social networks.

Francis likewise just recently ended American Cardinal Raymond Burke’s opportunities at the Vatican, withdrawing his income and right to a subsidized home. In a Nov. 20 conference, according to The Associated Press, the pope called Burke a source of “disunity” in the church.

In Germany, the Vatican has actually controlled the motion called the Synodal Path, which has actually seen bishops welcome progressive positions in the course of a two-year-long assessment with ordinary Catholics on the concerns of LGBTQ addition, ladies’s ordination and lay control. After a committee was commissioned to execute the motion’s propositions, the Vatican ruled that such a body would weaken the function of the bishops’ conference.

In a letter recently to German critics of the Synodal Path, Francis included his “issue” that the German church dangers breaking from communion with the remainder of the church.

Pope Francis throughout his weekly basic audience in St. Peter’s Square at the Vatican, on Oct. 18, 2023. (AP Photo/Alessandra Tarantino, File)

Arrieta explained the pope didn’t oppose the production of the Synodal Path’s committee however stated the entire church required to move together on teaching. “The contrast occurs when the doctrinal balance is doing not have,” Arrieta stated. “When bishops in a particular area wish to intrude in a field that worries the unity of the church, it’s clear that it develops issues.”

Arrieta likewise highlighted that canon law currently leaves adequate area for ordinary participation and involvement.

“The Second Vatican Council did an excellent task on the episcopate,” he stated, describing the reforms set in movement by the world’s Catholic bishops in the 1960s. The council offered bishops broad powers in their jurisdictions, which caused “terrific decentralization in the church,” stated Arrieta.

Arrieta enabled that some modifications to bishops’ function are in order. In October, numerous Catholic bishops assembled for the Synod on Synodality, signed up with by nuns, bros and laypeople, to think about the issues and needs of Catholics worldwide. In its report on its conversations, the synod recommended methods to modify the code of canon law to promote higher lay participation and more flattening of the church hierarchy.

“There are some concerns of involvement, extremely little, that might be quickly presented without altering a thing,” Arrieta stated, including that lots of bishops at the synod were shocked to understand just how much freedom canon law currently supplies to please the report’s recommendations.

Arrieta warned, nevertheless, that the code can’t be altered if its laws are based upon teaching. “I can consider a great deal of things that require reforming,” the bishop stated, “however there are limitations to just how much the hierarchical structure of the church can be reformed.”

Learn more