Synod on Synodality begins, with controversial matters and cooperation ‘intertwined’

VATICAN CITY (RNS) — A long-awaited monthlong gathering of Catholic leaders officially began at the Vatican on Wednesday (Oct. 2), charged by Pope Francis with making practical proposals to transform the church into a more welcoming and inclusive institution.

The summit, officially the Synod on Synodality — the latter term defined in Vatican documents as listening and discerning a way forward — includes 350 Catholic representatives, of whom 20% are lay faithful, including 54 women. These delegates will have the opportunity to vote on the synod’s final report, concluding a three-year process of consultation and debate at every level of the church.

Francis noted in his opening remarks that, while synods used to be limited exclusively for bishops in the past, that is no longer true today.

“The fact that we are gathered here — the bishop of Rome, bishops representing the worldwide episcopate, laymen and laywomen, consecrated men and women, deacons and priests as witnesses of the synodal journey, together with the fraternal delegates — is a sign of the church’s openness to listening to the voice of the Holy Spirit,” Francis said.

The pope said the gathering is only one step in a continuing journey to increase participation in the church and interpret the signs of what the church is being called to do. “Never can a bishop, or any other Christian, think of himself ‘without others.’ Just as no one is saved alone, the proclamation of salvation needs everyone, and requires that everyone to be heard,” Francis said.

The unprecedented consultation of Catholics that preceded the summit, beginning with discussion groups in parishes around the world, shed light on the tensions surrounding the most hotly debated topics in the church, from the welcoming of LGBTQ Catholics to the empowerment of women in the church.

While these topics were on the agenda in the first round of the synod a year ago, Francis later created 10 study groups, relegating them to theologians, canon lawyers and experts, who will offer their reports in 2025. The Vatican summit, the pope said, was to only focus on general topics of how to promote a synodal church.

“It’s up to us to point in the direction where we feel the Spirit is asking the entire church to go forth, by handing guidelines and perspectives to the Holy Father for the implementation phase,” said Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, secretary general of the Vatican’s synod office.

Hollerich said the work of the study groups and the discussions at the synod assembly “are intertwined” and that their creation represents a first step in enacting the proposals of the synod. The study groups are “road companions,” he said, pointing to how many of their members are also delegates at the synod.

The Vatican’s doctrine czar, Cardinal Manuel Fernandez, said his study group, on ministries not tied to ordination, will take into account the results of two commissions Francis created in 2016 and 2020 to study the possibility of women deacons. Deacons are permitted to preach the Gospel and oversee marriages and baptisms, but not say Mass or hear confessions.

Fernandez acknowledged that the pope considered the discussion of the female diaconate “as not yet mature” and cautioned against allowing women to become deacons without the appropriate reflection. “The diaconate risks becoming a consolation for women,” the cardinal said, “while the real participation of women remains neglected.”

The doctrinal head suggested there are better opportunities in the church that can be made available for women, which might allow them to have more authority than deacons, and asked synod participants to share their experiences.

Other study groups are addressing ecumenism, communion with Eastern Rite churches, poverty and promoting the work of religious sisters. Others are considering how to prepare seminarians, how to engage with Catholics in the digital world and who should have a say on selecting bishops and papal representatives.

The first session of the synod proper presented all the work that has been done since the last assembly last year, including reflections ranging from how to promote the role of pastors to how to quell the practice of polygamy, especially in Africa.

The relator general of the synod, Cardinal Mario Grech, said many believe “that the purpose of the synod is structural change in the church, is reform,” but noted that “we do not all have the same idea of reform and its priorities.”

But Grech emphasized the harmony inherent in the synod. “The fact that men and women have come from all parts of the earth to listen to the Spirit by listening to one another is a sign of contradiction for the world,” he said, describing the synod as “a proposal to today’s society,” which he said is marked by conflict and division.

“As we celebrate this assembly, wars are being fought in many parts of the world,” Grech told the assembly. “We are on the verge of a widening of the conflict. How many generations will have to pass before the warring peoples can once again ‘sit together’ and talk to each other, to build a peaceful future together?”